Carbon dioxide encourages ‘risky’ behavior in clownfish?

Alarmists reject natural selection again.

From the New Scientist:

Carbon dioxide in the ocean acts like alcohol on fish, leaving them less able to judge risks and prone to losing their senses. The intoxication adds to the threats that global warming and ocean acidification pose to marine ecosystems.

Around 2.3 billion tonnes of human-caused CO2 emissions dissolve into the world’s oceans every year, turning the water more acidic.

Philip Munday and colleagues at James Cook University in Townsville, Queensland, Australia, have previously found that if you put reef fish into water with more CO2 than normal in it – similar to the levels expected in oceans by the end of the century – they become bolder and attracted to odours they would normally avoid, including those of predators and unfavourable habitats.

Munday and his colleague Göran Nilsson at the University of Oslo, Norway, have now discovered that CO2 leads to riskier behaviour by interfering with a neurotransmitter receptor called GABA-A.

The pair reared clownfish (Amphiprion percula) larvae in seawater with normal (450 microatmospheres) and elevated (900 microatmospheres) CO2 levels. When they reached adulthood, the fish were given a choice between a water stream containing the odour of common predators such as the rock cod (Cephalopholis cyanostigma) or a stream lacking predatory odours. Those reared in high levels of CO2 swam towards rock cod’s scent around 90 per cent of the time, whereas those that had enjoyed normal levels of CO2 avoided the predator’s scent more than 90 per cent of the time.

Treating the clownfish bred under CO2-rich conditions with gabazine, a chemical that blocks the GABA-A receptor, helped them to regain their senses, though: fish treated this way swam towards the predatory smell only 12 per cent of the time.

“The fact that we could use a specific blocker for the GABA-A receptors to reverse the behavioural alterations proves that this receptor is involved in the CO2 effects,” says Nilsson…

Even accepting these results as true (and we don’t as, at the very least, the current clownfish population hasn’t been bred to thrive in high CO2 conditions), the reality is that over the next 100 years or so as CO2 levels double, the clownfish fit to thrive in higher CO2 seawater would would dominate the population.

It’s odd how alarmists who are often keen to accuse their opponents of not believing in evolution don’t seem to believe in it themselves.

5 thoughts on “Carbon dioxide encourages ‘risky’ behavior in clownfish?”

  1. CO2 is so much like a meme: broadcasted over and over again until you believe it. CO2 isn’t even a pollutant, so…

  2. Here is Junkscience. My reading is there is 800 billion tons of carbon from carbon dioxide dissolved in the top 100 meters of the ocean. (These writers are screwing up when they say 2.3 billion tons of carbon dioxide when I think they mean 2.3 billion tons of carbon from carbon dioxide.) The oceans are supposed to have absorbed 38,000 billion tons of carbon as carbon dioxide. What man does will never be noticed

    I am FOIA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.