Economist: Climate scepticism is not just American

CHRIS MOONEY has a new book out, “The Republican Mind” (here’s a brief essay-length version of the thesis), that looks from a frankly liberal standpoint at evidence that conservatives and liberals tend to have different character types and different attitudinal approaches to reality.

There’s plenty such evidence, and, before half the people who read this blog go ballistic, it really shouldn’t be considered offensive to point out the correlations between character types and political affiliation. Anyway, Mr Mooney thinks that in a broad variety of political clashes—and here I’m just describing Mr Mooney’s views so I can get to the main point—conservatives have a tendency to begin building alternate universes of fact that close off the possibility of debate. The most familiar and consequential example is the widespread conservative disbelief that the world is getting hotter, the sea level is rising, and it’s happening because humans burn fossil fuels. And the concomitant widespread belief that the scientific consensus on climate change is some form of conspiracy or hoax.

The thing is, whlle it makes sense that character types correlate with political persuasions, it doesn’t make sense to attribute specific political beliefs to character types. Conservative and liberal character types had different political convictions in 1650 than they do today (mostly), and they believe different things in Iran today than they do in America (mostly). Kevin Drum takes up this criticism with regard to climate change:

[T]he problem I have with Chris’s piece is this: temperament is universal, but Republicans are Americans. And it’s Republicans who deny global warming and evolution. European conservatives don’t. In fact, as near as I can tell, European conservatives don’t generally hold anti-science views any more strongly than European progressives.

I’m going to keep this post short because, as I said, I haven’t read the book. Maybe Chris addresses this at greater length there. But in the MoJo piece, at least, he doesn’t really address the question of why differences in brain wiring have produced such extreme anti-science views in American conservatives but not in European conservatives. So consider this an invitation, Chris. Is your contention that American conservatives are unique in some way? Or that American brains are wired differently? Or am I wrong about European conservatives?

I think that on climate change, Mr Drum is somewhat wrong about European conservatives. In the Netherlands, at least, the climate-change debate functions in much the same way it does in America, if less intensely.

Economist

About these ads

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s